• Follow us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • Contact us

Getting access to our website

Read more

Search form
GLEN SANNOX © Richard Seville

GLEN SANNOX © Richard Seville

CMAL opposes direct ferry awards to Ferguson Marine as MSPs hear GLEN SANNOX and GLEN ROSA may never run on LNG

FerryCaledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) chief executive Kevin Hobbs told Holyrood’s transport committee on 18 November that he and the CMAL board were “100%” opposed to a direct award to Ferguson Marine for the second phase of the Small Vessels Replacement Programme. The phase covers two, or possibly three, small electric ferries for the Sound of Harris and the Sound of Barra. Scottish ministers pledged the work to the state-owned yard in March.

Hobbs said the preliminary work was complete, but the project was on hold while ministers considered how a direct award could be made. He believed such an award was not currently lawful. It might become possible next year after planned changes to CMAL’s governance, and the board would have to be instructed by ministers as sole shareholder. “While we want to see that shipyard survive, we do not believe building ferries there is the right thing to do for the island communities,” he said, pointing to the delays and overspends on GLEN SANNOX and GLEN ROSA. In a letter to Transport Scotland he described a direct award as “problematic at best and folly at worst”, and said CMAL wanted an open international tender.

Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn told the same session that the government remained committed to the direct award. Ferguson Marine said it had a proud shipbuilding record. The GMB union said CMAL was itself responsible for many of the problems. CMAL has not placed a shipbuilding contract with a UK yard since 2015. The first phase of the programme, seven small ferries, went to Remontowa in Gdansk last year.

At the same hearing, MSPs were told that GLEN SANNOX and GLEN ROSA may never run on the LNG they were designed for, The Scotsman reports. The cost of the fuel and of building storage tanks at the ports puts its use in doubt. “There is a question mark. It will hinge on the investment case to put LNG facilities to where that vessel will run from,” CalMac chief executive Duncan Mackison said. He agreed that CalMac would not use LNG if the price was too high. Hobbs said LNG had been seen as the “fuel for the future” but its price had “escalated beyond anything anybody could ever have imagined”. Committee convener Willie Rennie called the situation the “ultimate farce”.

GLEN SANNOX entered service last year, six years late. Because Scotland has no LNG supply, the fuel had to be brought 500 miles by road tanker from Kent. She was first deployed on Troon–Brodick, then moved in the summer to the Western Isles, where there is no access to LNG. GLEN ROSA is due on the Arran route next spring if she is completed by her latest deadline in February. Both ships are four times over budget.

© Shippax

nov 19 2026


Get the latest news - for FREE

Receive our weekly newsletter with the latest news and unique special offers.

Products

Shippax Info

Our monthly magazine + Online Access.1 year subscription.

More

Shippax Market 26

Market reports & outlook

More

Shippax Guide 26

JANTAR UNITY

More

Shippax Designs 25

STENA FUTURA

More

Shippax Database - Single user

Shippax Database online

More

Don’t miss out!

The place to meet the ferry shipping industry!